Elevate With Elsner
Welcome to "Elevate with Elsner," the podcast that dives deep into the stories of individuals who've taken the bold step to follow their passion and make an impact!
I'm Blake Elsner, a real estate professional by day and your host by passion. I've always believed that our true calling can often be found in the most unexpected places. That's why I'm thrilled to bring you inspiring conversations with amazing guests who have transformed their lives by pursuing work they truly love.
Each episode of "Elevate with Elsner" is packed with candid discussions, heartfelt stories, and practical advice from people who took the leap and never looked back.
Whether it's leaving the corporate grind to start a business, swapping a finance job for a creative career, or any other impactful journey, you'll hear it all right here.
We'll explore the highs and lows, the challenges and triumphs, and most importantly, the impact these changes have made not just in their lives, but in the lives of others.
So, if you're ready to be inspired, if you're dreaming of making a change, or if you just love a good story of passion and impact, "Elevate with Elsner" is the podcast for you!
Subscribe now on your favorite podcast platform and join us on this journey of transformation and discovery.
Can’t wait for you to tune in, listen to passion stories and know that even you can make an impact on the next episode of "Elevate with Elsner." See you next time!
Let’s elevate together!
Elevate With Elsner
UAD 3.6 And The New Appraisal Reality
Appraisals can feel like the one part of a deal nobody controls, until you understand what appraisers and lenders are actually working with. We bring you a real conversation with Dan Crowley, a 25-year real estate appraiser, and Drew Quidonis from USA Mortgage to cut through the noise around UAD 3.6. The new appraisal reporting standard adds a lot more required data fields, but it does not magically change how value is determined. What it does change is the workflow, and that’s where good agents can make deals smoother.
We get specific about how to prepare a listing for an appraisal in an MLS-driven world: naming rooms clearly, showing where bedrooms and baths sit by level, and accurately reporting finished basement square footage and room types. Dan explains why those details matter inside the new UAD format, and Drew shares what lenders are seeing on appraisal turn times and closing schedules, especially when inspections and negotiations compress the calendar.
Then we tackle the stress points that cause the most friction: low appraisals, reconsiderations of value, and why “it should have appraised” is often a comps problem, not an appraiser problem. We also clarify a big source of confusion for buyers and agents alike: basement bedrooms, egress windows, and why below-grade space gets value credit without being counted the same as above-grade bedrooms. Finally, Drew breaks down appraisal waivers and hybrid options like ACE and property data collection, plus what today’s buyer leverage looks like with seller credits and temporary rate buydowns.
If you want cleaner appraisals, fewer surprises, and better outcomes for buyers and sellers, subscribe, share this with an agent or lender in your circle, and leave a review with your biggest appraisal question.
From excavation and grading to site preparation and underground projects, Mike and the team at St. Louis Excavation bring experience, reliability, and hard work to every job.
Proudly serving the St. Louis area, they're committed to quality work and getting the job done right.
Elevate with Elsner is proudly sponsored by St. Louis Excavation. Supporting local businesses that help build St. Louis from the ground up!
When sewer and drain problems strike, you need someone you can trust. That's where Kevin and the team at River City Sewer & Drain come in!
Proudly serving the St. Louis area, River City Sewer & Drain helps homeowners tackle sewer and drain issues with dependable service, honest communication, and a commitment to getting the job done right.
From clogged drains to unexpected sewer problems, River City is a local company you can count on.
🎙️ PROUDLY SPONSORED BY
RIVER CITY SEWER & DRAIN
Elevate with Elsner is proudly sponsored by River City Sewer & Drain, a locally owned and operated St. Louis-area company led by Kevin Mahoney.
Serving the community for over 20 years, Kevin and his team specialize in sewer camera inspections, drain cleaning, hydro jetting, sewer line locating, and more.
📍 Serving St. Louis, St. Charles & Jefferson Counties
🌐 https://www.rivercityseweranddrains.com
🚨 24/7 Emergency Service Available
SAINT LOUIS EXCAVATION
Proudly sponsored by Mike Petzhold and the team at Saint Louis Excavation!
From excavation and digging to underground pipe replacement and site work, Mike and his crew tackle the tough jobs that keep projects moving forward.
Saint Louis Excavation — Local Experts. Proven Results.
Website: https://stlexcavation.com
Phone: (314) 709-6219
Email: info@stlexcavation.com
Support the businesses that support Elevate with Elsner!
Why Appraisals Matter Right Now
Blake ElsnerAll right, good morning, everybody. And first off, thanks for joining us here on a Wednesday morning. Today we're going to dive into something that obviously impacts just about every real estate transaction. That's appraisals, obviously. And there's a lot happening in the appraisal world right now, especially with the rollout of the new UAD 3.6 appraisal reporting system, changes to how properties are documented and what all this could mean for realtors, lenders, buyers, and sellers. But here's the deal we don't want this to be another webinar where you just sit here, a bunch of terminology, and wondering, you know, if you actually learned anything. So we want me to we want you to bring questions to us, and we want you to leave today with something you can use on your next transaction. So we're going to kind of open the floor to just a conversation to be had, questions to be answered. It's pretty rare you get to sit down with an appraiser and a lender at the same time and kind of conversate about different things, questions, issues you've had in the past. I mean anything that you want to bring forth. We're going to talk about how to prepare, you know, a listing for an appraisal, understanding what happens when a property doesn't appraise, stuff like that. And then that's the goal. So we're going to have some great conversations. We got Dan Crowley with property valuation, who's going to help us understand the appraisal side. And then, of course, we got Drew Q with USA Mortgage, who's joining us to bring another perspective, obviously, to the conversation. He obviously deals with appraisers every single day. So we want to emphasize one thing. This is definitely an open conversation. So feel free to leave your comments in basically on Facebook, YouTube, inside the StreamYard webinar, and we will answer those as they come in as well. So, first off, let's go ahead and introduce Dan. Dan, why don't you take it away and tell people a little bit about yourself and kind of how long you've been in the business?
SPEAKER_01Sure. I'm Dan Crowley with property valuation. I've been a real estate appraiser for 25 years and excited to be here.
Blake ElsnerIt's a lot of a lot of appraisals, 25 years.
SPEAKER_01Right.
Blake ElsnerYou know, and with these new changes, a lot of it, you know, at first I think we thought it was some crazy changes, and they're not really as crazy as they're not kind of all thought. So that's the that's the good part. Um, as we kind of break into that. On the flip side, on the lender side, Drew, introduce yourself. Most people know you.
SPEAKER_02What's up? What's up? Drew Quidonis, USA Mortgage, do a lot of residential mortgages. Things are good, and and it's it was nice. Appreciate you putting this together, kind of giving people, I think get rid of some of the fear-mongering, give people a little bit better perspective. That yes, this is a major change. Yes, this has kind of been a pain in the butt for real estate agents and lenders, but there's ways to make it a little bit more streamlined, make it a little bit less painful. That's kind of our goal is to let people know that stuff will still be, I think, business as usual.
Blake ElsnerYeah, that's it. That and that's the biggest part, I think. Yeah, business as usual is kind of more, it's just more work on certain sides. So let's just jump in to basically let's just start with the new changes. Dan, kind of
Meet The Appraiser And Lender
Blake Elsnerwalk us through is it more work for you, for the lender, for the you know, the seller? Who exactly is this change for?
SPEAKER_01The change I is primarily for the appraisers. The form is more data entry, and it it does take a little bit longer, but I think the more you get comfortable with the report, it's not overwhelming or anything. You know, it's it's manageable.
Blake ElsnerAnd when you mean like when you go through these, you know, I think it was 200 data entries that you had to do. Now it's I believe what'd you say over 2000?
SPEAKER_01Correct. It it's form-filling, a lot of point and click. Less less narrative.
Blake ElsnerAnd I think one of the things that kind of gets I think is confusing in this whole process is all those data entries really aren't changing per se the structure of the value, right?
SPEAKER_01Correct.
Blake ElsnerSo that's why I think uh in terms of now when you go to from a from a listings, you know, a listing standpoint, a listing side, and I'm gonna, you know, sell a house, I'm gonna enter it into MLS. Is it important? Should we do anything different in the MLS input?
SPEAKER_01I think there's two areas that I would stress that would be important is on your locating where all the rooms are, and like how many bedrooms are on the main floor, or if it's a two-story, how many are on the second floor, along with bathrooms. And then the other thing, when there's basement finish, entering the square footage of the finished area, and what rooms are down there. That that would be the the two biggest changes for on the listing side.
Blake ElsnerAnd something about like when we when we go into the listing input side and we're we're saying it's a three-bed, you know, two-bath house, we should go through and actually list each room or bedroom, right? Uh, on the listing input to make it uh better for you all, correct?
SPEAKER_01Correct. Yes.
Blake ElsnerSo I think some people will they won't put like
UAD 3.6 Adds Major Data Entry
Blake Elsnerbedroom, bedroom two, family room, living room, rec room. That that needs to be that's an important thing to make sure that's always in your MLS input. Most of us do it, I think, but there are a few times where you go out and you pull up an ML MLS input sheet and you see that those aren't listed like that. So
SPEAKER_01I
Blake Elsnerthink that's a those those two things are a good. Now, what about the remarks? Should we be talking about different things inside the the marketing remarks?
SPEAKER_01When there's updates, I would just think my somehow describe the updates or or just list the updates. That that's very beneficial.
Blake ElsnerLike, yeah, okay. And obviously prepare your anything that's been renovated, any permits, you know, improvements, and obviously another thing you were talking about was to put the total living area, correct?
SPEAKER_01Yes. So
Blake Elsnernot above ground.
SPEAKER_01Square footage for the above ground, and and then also it's really important for the square footage of the finished area in the basement.
Blake ElsnerYeah, I think that's another big part that some people we just are like, ah, we don't know, so we just skip over it, and that obviously is doing a disservice to your seller and your client. So I think for all of us, those are three or four different tips that we should probably do going forward. So obviously for this UAD 3.6, it became mandatory for most submissions. I know you can like request certain, I guess, things until I think it's through end of May of 27. Um so what from a Drew, let's jump over to you from a from a lender standpoint. What is there anything that is changing that you need to tell buyers about?
SPEAKER_02I think when it first came out, there was a lot of fear of this is going to significantly shift time frames. This is going to, we need to prep our buyers, sellers, listing agents need to know that closings will not happen as soon as they have been. And that was kind of the word and everything that was kind of preached throughout the entire industry with this change. Luckily, I know we do some stuff with Dan. You know, there's a lot of really good appraisers out there that are you know learning this new type of form and able to still keep you know turn times that we need. And, you know, and and what we need is really anywhere between, you know, five to ten days sometimes, you know, on a turn time, around a week is really when we order it. You know, that's kind of uh in somewhat our expectations. If it needs to be rushed, we can let them know. If we have some time, we'll let them know. But you know, we we are still from our conversations with not only Dan but other appraisers, that time frame is still okay to be met. It's definitely a little bit more work on their side right now, but that's kind of why we're talking of what can agents do to help these appraisers complete their appraisal a lot sooner and more efficiently so that we don't have to worry that much about these time frames. You know, I I'm still seeing, like I said, I'm still seeing weeks back, you know, about a week back. So we're not, you know, raising the flags on any of this, you know, fear in a sense of stuff getting pushed back. I would not buy too into that as long as you guys can help out appraisers as much as possible.
Blake ElsnerYeah, and I believe jumping back to Dan, he had said that you know, the old ones he could he could do one and fill out the paperwork in maybe an hour, and I think now it's doubled now two hours. So we're hoping that obviously if it's still new, when it's taking two hours, that hopefully that's kind of the max that it it'll take. And I think as realtors, we we kind of tend to just think, you know, appraisals, we order it, lender does it all. We don't really ever really think about it, but there's obviously people on the other other end of of appraisals and and everything. So I think if if need be, we're just gonna have to, you know, you order it a little sooner, and that's just part of the process anyway. If you've got to order it a day before they usually do, I don't think it's gonna change too much, of course, unless you're you know in the midst of some crazy
MLS Inputs That Prevent Appraisal Delays
Blake Elsnerinspections or etc. So
SPEAKER_02I think too what what people don't remember or think about in terms of appraisals. And can you guys still hear
SPEAKER_01me
SPEAKER_02okay? Because I did something what one thing that people forget about appraisals. Yes, it's important for the buyer, the person buying the home, it is important for them to know that this $350,000 house is worth at least $350,000 or more. That is unbelievably important. But people forget that the appraisal actually has a lot more weight for that investor or that servicer that is actually taking on that loan. And the reason is they need to make sure that the money that they are giving this borrower to lend them, they are making sure that that asset that they are lending on, that they are taking a risk on is has that value. Okay, and so when we're looking at adding, you know, fields and adding additional stuff, as much of a pain in the butt it can be for not only appraisers, but also the time frames that we can run into. This is extremely important to keep the industry pure and that people are getting homes that they need and that investors are still keeping up their time frames. You know, so we look at it like that. Yes, I talked to the borrowers. Yes, it's important to know you're buying a home that makes sense and you know is worth what you are buying it for. But also it's very important that you know that value is what that investor is lending on to keep the industry continuing.
Blake ElsnerYeah, those are those are all really good, good points, Drew. What what would you say like have you really had to change anything like in terms of your process?
SPEAKER_02No, I mean, like we we obviously kind of overpromise, excuse me, underpromise, overperform. Yeah, we overpromise and underperform over here. It's a great business model. I'd give everybody that tip. We're trying to over underpromise in terms of that time frame. We're not necessarily pushing purchase prices or excuse me, closing dates too far out, necessarily. I mean, we're still trying to keep and stay competitive at that 30 days, but we're true. So I think what gets tricky is a lot of times I like to wait until that inspection has been complete before we order that appraisal. I don't really want the borrower spending a lot of money. And and what gets tricky is sometimes we go through inspections, we're going through repairs, we're going through negotiations on that point. What's tricky about that is we start getting a little tight on that time frame of when the appraisal can be in and when loan commitment is. So I like to make sure, I like to make sure that the inspections are okay or we still have time. And right now, what we're doing is we're just making sure that that appraisal and those inspections are done so that we're not scrambling last minute for that appraisal and loan commitment to get done. But to kind of answer your question, I know it's long, but nothing major really on my side. I mean, nothing major that is changing that really real estate agents should be too concerned about.
Blake ElsnerOkay, that's that's good. So, what do you do you recommend like appraisal gaps, like putting that type of stuff in there? Like if a buyer comes to you, Drew, and wants to, you know, put that in a contract. Do you recommend doing this stuff?
SPEAKER_02You know, it's it that was so much more relevant when we were in a lot more of a seller's market, right? You know, when buyers had to be super competitive, when we were, you know, offering the kitchen everything in our left arm, we really had to get creative. I just am not seeing gaps really that often. I do see really quality homes still being very competitive, still needing to give a really good offer, but man, I mean, like 60, 70, 80 percent of my recent deals that are purchases are getting seller credit. So we're not really needing an like we're not really needing to issue or you know, have an appraisal gap inside of our contract because a lot of times we have a lot of leverage, and that's I think not to sell. I mean, it's easy to sell and it's easy to ride this this trail, but like we are more so in a buyer's market than we've been in in years, and so buyers have a lot of leverage. You don't need to waive these inspections, this appraisal, offer an appraisal gap, knowing you're gonna overbuy. You have a lot of leverage, so you know, is it is it beneficial on a really nice home? It absolutely can be, you know, and you as a listing agent, you know, will see
Turn Times And Smarter Ordering Strategy
SPEAKER_02that and be able to explain that to your sellers, but I'm not seeing that necessarily as much of a as a necessity with how the market is.
Blake ElsnerYeah, that's true with all the credits like nowadays. Um it's so true. Like I'm closing on one tomorrow that they have a a credit too. So I feel like even if you know you don't need like money for a closing cost, obviously you can get a credit to buy down your rate. And I think that's another, like, even if I joke, like you know, if you're gonna give them full price, maybe write five over, get the five back,
SPEAKER_02and use
Blake Elsnerthat to buy down your rate or the whatever the percentage is.
SPEAKER_02I think I know this is appraisals, but even talking about appraisals value, you know, leverage that buyers have, it is it is absolutely crazy, just even how little amount you need from the seller to be able to do a temporary buy downs. Right now, I have a guy, he's looking at a seven hundred thousand dollar house. That's obviously a really large purchase price. And but with really large purchase prices, you can get sometimes like ten thousand dollars on a on a seven hundred thousand dollar house is a lot different than ten thousand dollars on a two hundred fifty thousand dollar house, right? So we are asking for, I think it's gonna come out to about twelve, thirteen thousand on the on the sorry, I got this coming through two different modes that I got two, let's see, it's about twelve thousand dollars that we are asking for a seller credit. They're actually gonna save about seven hundred and fifty dollars on the first year because we're gonna do a temporary two-one buy down. First rate's gonna be in the fives, they're gonna save about 300-ish, almost 400 in the second year, because now it's gonna be down into the six. So then that year three and on will be in that seven percent interest rate range. And our hope is that interest rates maybe can get down to the sixes for us to refinance. And again, that's only about twelve thousand dollars to be saving a huge chunk for the short term.
Blake ElsnerYeah, I can't. That's a tremendous, tremendous thing to do, especially like to have three years of hope for rates to to dip back down. Like, I don't think there's a much like a better product that you could get into to help you, you know, relieve some of that, like you said, that's that's quite quite the savings over the course of that time and not a lot out of like the seller's pocket, like you're saying. So appreciate that. So jumping back, Dan.
SPEAKER_01Yes, uh
Blake Elsnerwhen you when you go to like appraise a house and you have the sale contract in front of you, kind of is that how how much like leverage, or do you do you ever like look at like the days on market, or did you know like hey, they had 20 offers, or how does that ever come about?
SPEAKER_01The only time it comes about is when the listing agent provides it, and I find it extremely helpful when there's multiple offers. Some of the some agents will say, Okay, we got let's say there's 10 offers, they got four cash offers, they got four real clean offers, one you know, they give us the scenario, the layout of of kind of the offers. It it kind of helps. I usually put it in the report.
Blake ElsnerThat's that's really important stuff right there. That uh because
SPEAKER_01then I feel like the lender when I appraise it, let's let's use Drew's number, the 700,000. Let's say I come in at 715 or 720, but there was demand and there was multiple offers, and I say I give them the breakdown of what the offers were. I think I think lenders like it.
Blake ElsnerWould you agree, Drew, with that?
SPEAKER_02I don't necessarily see the like the secondary market, because really what he's kind of hinting at is the secondary market of you know how appealing is this loan. You know, you look at the big short, you know, you had really, really bad loans in what were described as good loans and good categories. So what he's kind of hitting at is like these truly, you know, these are going into a good bucket and truly have you know the value, really have the interest. I think he's I think he's spot on.
Blake ElsnerYeah, that that's that is well, that's good information right there, good dialogue. But what it in terms of I guess the listing side, so how can like how does a listing agent contact you? Obviously, they do they go through like the lender. If if I'm a listing agent and I got a buyer coming in and it's another agent on the other end, how does that how do they get a hold of you?
SPEAKER_01Normally it's when we schedule the appointment through showing time, they they see who the appraiser is, and then they'll reach out.
Blake ElsnerThat's and that obviously is obviously great agents who are gonna do that, and it's it's gonna be the same agent that fills out the the input in the MLS properly, puts the rooms. It just sets it up for so much more success so that way you don't have to go back and go to Drew and say, Hey Drew, we need to figure out how to do, you know, a what do they call it? A what's a second opinion or a recalculation?
SPEAKER_01Repressive value consideration.
Blake ElsnerSo how does that work?
SPEAKER_01So generally it's it's between the loan officer and the borrower. And if there's an agent involved, the agent per will help provide comps that they feel should have been used. And they'll write a little description under them, like, you know, this one is similar condition, this one similar square footage, or and and then we have to look at the the comparables that were provided and just and determine if they're worth putting in the report or the reason why we would not include them.
SPEAKER_02Well, and what what gets tricky too is it kind of gets
Buyer Leverage Seller Credits And Buydowns
SPEAKER_02into like interesting territory because like let's say we got a $350,000 house and the appraisal comes back at $330,000. Okay, so we're $20,000 under of true, and and Dan, it's not your job to ruin deals. You know, it's not it's it's your job to keep the integrity in the market, making sure that we are not just letting purchase prices explode. I mean, these comps truly, this is data. And so the problem is we fight to get $350, and it's it gets tricky because is that in the buyer's best interest? You know, and that's like you said, we we go to the buyer, you know, like when that comes in, comes in at 330, you know. Yes, I I I like talking with the agent first, you know, kind of letting them know and just get it in their get it in their radar, put it on their plate of, hey, I'm going to the borrower, we're gonna chat. I need to let them, I need to let get an idea of if this borrow is like, no, this is worth 330, like we have a we have a very we have a professional opinion saying this is 330, why would I pay 350? But some borrowers like, no, this is this is my home, this is absolutely what I need. There's comps that support this. We want to keep the values of the of the neighborhood, let's go fight this, you know, that's fine, but a lot of people like immediately like let's we gotta we gotta fight this, we gotta fight this. It might not be in the best interest of the buyer.
SPEAKER_01And in full disclosure, my my rule of thumb is if I have a deal that I think could be coming in lower than the contract, I always contact the listing agent and just say, you know, coming in a little bit low, am I missing something? And then we have the conversation.
SPEAKER_02So I I want to get kind of hard on real estate agents because I like listing agents are looking or I mean just real estate agents in general are looking at almost the exact same information that you are looking at, correct, Dan?
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_02So it really should not be a surprise. I mean, it really, if we know we're gonna be low, it almost should be communicated to me or going forward that like, hey, we're gonna be really hoping for 350. Everything shows 330 to 340. Like 350, that'd be amazing. It really shouldn't be like 330. Are you kidding me? Like, I mean, am I wrong?
SPEAKER_01Right, I agree.
SPEAKER_02I I just and again, I'm getting hard, but like now the the problem is it's now it falls on me, and I'm always fine falling on the sword. That's fine, but like now falls on me that the lender's appraisal came in low, you know, the lender, and truly, like I'm Mr. Fix it. I always really wish I could, I'm always trying to find solutions, but in reality, it's like, no, this professional says this. The same numbers that you guys look at show this. It it's not necessarily something that should be like a crazy question. Yes, of course, five, ten thousand of an opinion of certain upgrades, sure. But I've had appraisals come in super low, and everybody's like, Are you kidding me? This is ridiculous. And it's like, I don't know what you want me to tell you sometimes.
Blake ElsnerYou do you mean from like a pricing standpoint? Because what if somebody just comes in and you know they just pay way over and they think it's worth that? Is that like
SPEAKER_02100? No, that's absolutely different.
Blake ElsnerThat's fine, okay.
SPEAKER_01Yeah,
SPEAKER_02that's a hundred percent different. That's always communicated, but I'm like, I feel like I run into so much it's at 350. We, you know, or or because it's it could be a mixture of both, of both the listing agent and the buyer's agent, of it's listed at 350 and that appraisal comes back at 330, and everybody's confused, but everybody was maybe assuming that appreciation was doing better than what it was, or the upgrades are better than what they are, you know, than what some of those comps say. So I just I don't know if again I'm being hard on real estate agents, but it I'm not gonna, you know, hold you guys tight. Like I'm I wanna, you know, I'm just I'm always curious of like, is this a really a surprise, or were we really just hoping? Because if we were really hoping, I'm on board with that. I'm perfectly fine with that. But if it's a true surprise, then that's where I feel like there's a miss, you know, suit a super large disconnect.
SPEAKER_01Yeah,
Blake Elsnerit's just yeah, it's like doing your job wrong, and then everyone else kind of needs to pay for it in a way.
SPEAKER_02It's not that common. I don't really want to make it seem like that common everybody works with. It's just you know, you get random deals here and there that the appraisals come in significantly less, and they're questioning me. You know, what do you mean? I'm like, what do you mean? What do you mean? Like, I'm just as surprised as you. Honestly, I could I can't, I can look on you know where I'm gonna look at Zillow. I'm gonna look at some of our estimate calculators. That's that's what I have access to. I don't have MLS access,
SPEAKER_01right?
Blake ElsnerYeah, and part of it, I guess, too, is some people I think pull comps a different way, and I think honestly, you kind of have to be taught like how to pull proper comps because especially in St. Louis, like it's so unique that it's you really have to be, you know, it's just like some of these like like Limburg schools are like you know, you're in gosh, what's an example? Kirkwood, and part of Kirkwood has Limburg schools and like stuff like that. So you can't pull Kirkwood schools on those comps, right? And so like people are like, wait a minute, there's Limburg school districts in Kirkwood. I'm like, yeah, go back behind certain like back off forest back there. And it's like certain areas back there, it's weird because like you have you have to just it's so selective on how you run these comps. I think maybe even a comp class is probably something that should be taught.
SPEAKER_01It could be helpful,
Blake Elsnerespecially because if they see how you do it, you know, if if it should be very similar, right? True, it's the same data, like you said, then if if we watched an appraiser do it, we should be able to price it the same way,
SPEAKER_01right?
SPEAKER_02And I'm and I'm okay, like I said, I'm okay a few thousand, maybe even five of ten, honestly. I mean ten might even be a little out there, but it's just it always, you know, I I and and like you said, I think it's just the the research or this the skills of just truly comping things correctly, certain two-bedroom giving giving certain giving, I think maybe two, giving certain credit or value for certain upgrades that maybe actually don't have true appraisal guideline value, if that makes sense.
SPEAKER_01Yeah,
Blake Elsneryeah, it does. Another thing we were talking about when we were all chatting together was
Low Appraisals And Value Reconsiderations
Blake Elsnerabout like total bedrooms and egress windows. And Drew brought up a great point talking about his house. Like, you know, we have a he's got a bedroom and it's got an egress window. Is that in the basement? Is that considered a bedroom? And so, like, let's dive through that, Dan. Like, tell us a little bit about what you know in the basement, because a lot of people are like, you know, is it a bedroom? Like, how do we do how do you count a bedroom in the basement?
SPEAKER_01Okay, so obviously the bedroom in the basement needs an egress window and a closet. Where the where the confusion comes in is when there's basement finish and there's a say a bedroom, bathroom, and a family room, it's a separate line item than the main floor rooms or above ground above grade. They're two separate line items. So how I would describe it is Drew has a three-bedroom house with two bathrooms and a finished lower level with a family room, a bedroom, and a bathroom. And then he gets credit for the square footage of the finished area and whatever rooms are down there. And then if I have a comp that has basement finish but only has a family room, I make the adjustment for the bedroom there in the basement finish area.
Blake ElsnerWhich is gonna hold quite a bit of weight, right?
SPEAKER_01Correct. Correct. I mean so yes, he does have a bedroom, but it's just it his house is not a four-bedroom house right now. It's still a three-bed with a basement finish in a in a bedroom in the basement.
Blake ElsnerWhich he still can list. Yeah, it's credit
SPEAKER_01for.
Blake ElsnerYeah, it's still
SPEAKER_01so I mean it it it helps the value tremendously.
Blake ElsnerOkay. That's see, I think that's a very confusing and the egress window also has to be in the bedroom. Right.
SPEAKER_01Correct. Yes. I get that all the time.
Blake ElsnerYeah. So that's why those egress windows, I think, are such, I mean, they're great investments if you have a a bedroom, a room down there, because like you say, you're gonna add a tremendous amount of value by you know, those windows I think now are like 75, maybe 10 grand. I'm not really sure, somewhere around that.
SPEAKER_01Right.
Blake ElsnerBut obviously, you're gonna recoup that value by adding a bedroom down there. So I think that's great. And same with a bath. So that's all good information. Say that again, Andrew.
SPEAKER_02Well, uh, so to clarify, it's in that three-bedroom, two bath with the bedroom downstairs, it's still a three-bedroom, two-bath in terms of looking at comps, but you can add, you can you look at those two homes, three-bedroom, two bath, three-bedroom, two bath, but you add a little bit more value because of that bedroom. And then even if this one has a finished, they both have finished basements, you're gonna give a little bit more value because of that bedroom, correct?
SPEAKER_01Oh, for sure. Yes, and it's usually quite a bit.
SPEAKER_02Is it do you I mean, I know this is maybe impossible to say how how much of a difference is it versus like it truly being a four-bedroom as in the main living area? Half?
SPEAKER_01Yes, yes, half is a good rule of thumb.
SPEAKER_02I'm and and I know that's all over the place, you know. I
SPEAKER_01guess
SPEAKER_02I think that's the biggest, you know, we we talked about this, like on Zillow, you go to a home and it says it's 3,000 square feet, and you're like, amazing. And then you look at it, it's like a little ranch, and you're like, how you know, I say little, but say it's an 1800 square foot ranch, you know, with 1,200 finished downstairs. I mean, they're they're showing living, and again, we kind of said, you know, it's living space, but that's I mean, that's kind of the idea. So now people are running maybe comps on a four-bedroom, three bath, and that and what you're saying is that's incorrect. You can't be running comps like
SPEAKER_01correct, yes, yes, and that is very confusing, and that happens a lot on for sale by owner deals. Because if they're getting them off of Zillow,
SPEAKER_02sure.
SPEAKER_01We we all know Zillow doesn't have the most accurate info.
Blake ElsnerI think that's a really good, solid uh point right there. Is I think most of us are gonna, even myself, honestly, I feel like I I'm gonna run comps almost like a four-bedroom if it's got a bedroom down there. But that's good to know that hey, it's gonna take you almost need to go dive into the comps more and try to find that's why that data is so important because then you can pull comps from a pre from other listings that are actually filled out properly, so then you can take that and see like, hey, there was this fourth bedroom in the basement, therefore, let's use this comp over the fourth bedroom that's on the main floor.
SPEAKER_01Correct.
Blake ElsnerThat's I think that's that's valid, valid stuff that is is good to take, I think.
SPEAKER_02Well, and Dan, I wrote down a question too. Just I know this comes up a lot. I mean, what are you know, you this kind of appraiser/slash real estate hat on? What is uh the most bang for your buck upgrade that somebody can do to their home, whether they're thinking about selling, you know, within the next year or two, you know, I'm obviously we could say kitchen and drop a hundred grand, but I mean, reasonably saying, I mean, what is like a project that somebody could tackle? I think a lot of people have been in their homes for a while, they're maybe getting dated. What is a what is a true valuable upgrade that people can kind of tackle to give their home a little bit more jazz?
SPEAKER_01Uh, I think in the last 10 years, the number one thing I would say after kitchen and bathrooms is basement finish. And you have a number of reasons why. Men with fantasy football. See,
SPEAKER_02my basement, it is a fantasy football, that is for sure.
SPEAKER_01Kids with gaming, parents working from home more. I cannot tell you how many times I've gone into a house and like the the family room isn't on the main floor, it's down in the basement. It's you know, I've been in homes where there's no TV on the main floor. I mean, when I got into business, that was unheard of. And and now it's it's kind of common that you know the TV and the setup is down in the basement.
SPEAKER_02Do you think do you think because I mean a lot of two stories obviously don't have the basement and the bot, you know, the the you know, I have a ranch in my basement, it can be really spread. Do you think people should focus more on a larger living space in their basement or smaller with a with a bedroom as well?
SPEAKER_01I think it really depends on what you can get get down there. I I'm still a big fan of if it's roughed in for a bathroom, adding a bathroom and then having a big like family room. Oh like a big open space with a bathroom.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I agree. I agree. We I mean we're we're one of millions of people that bought when rates were really low, bought a home that we thought was gonna be five or six years, and here we are at five or six years, and we were just like, let's do the basement. Let's get because I mean all we're doing is hanging out in the living room, you know, upstairs. It's like we need some space. I got two littles that are running, and you know, they need some room, so it's
Basement Bedrooms Egress And How To Count
SPEAKER_02nice to know any any home. I even remember when I was looking, I even remember buddies when they're buying. It's like I always love looking at the basement and visualizing TV's gonna be here. You put a little wet bar right there, you know. It's it's great,
SPEAKER_01right?
SPEAKER_02It's got some great opportunities.
SPEAKER_01Yes. Yes.
Blake ElsnerDan, going back to like in terms of like orders and such, are you seeing like because obviously you get a pretty good pulse of the market. Are you seeing a lot of stuff still, you know, kind of appreciating like price-wise, or are you running into a lot of low appraisals?
SPEAKER_01I am not running into any low appraisals. What I am seeing, I know this isn't necessarily your question, but what I'm seeing is the market, I'm not seeing as many multiple offers, and I'm seeing things with longer days on the market, and then I'm also seeing buyers negotiating. Not much, but a little bit.
Blake ElsnerThat's a strong, strong take, obviously, because like Drew had mentioned, it I think I think we've never been more in a buyer's market in the past like decade, right? Wouldn't you agree? I mean, you're you're seeing all these price cuts too. Like, I think somebody had posted recently about I think there was like 2,500 price cuts or something like that of on the like new listing, like something crazy to where like the amount of movement inside the market is like driven by price cuts almost now. And that seems to be an interesting thing.
SPEAKER_01I think the rule of thumb though is like if it's priced right out of the gate, it will sell really quick. If it's high, it it might sit and you might do a couple price reductions and end up getting a little bit less than what you would have if it was priced right.
Blake ElsnerI know I always joke. I I kind of wish you know we would all just put a dollar into every
SPEAKER_02just an open market.
Blake ElsnerYeah, just like you know, you can't you can't put a price, you gotta put a dollar, and we all gotta go figure it out. Like, you know what I'm saying? Like everyone's gotta take data, and you you really gotta figure out your numbers because I mean there'd be people out there, I feel like appraisers would hate that one, but yeah, they'd be like, wait a minute, what's going on here? Like, we got we got offers all over the board, we got inexperienced
SPEAKER_027,000 people were interested. I mean, there was a lot of interest. It just yeah,
Blake ElsnerI guess somebody offered two dollars.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, right,
Blake Elsnerand appraised, yeah,
SPEAKER_02yeah.
Blake ElsnerSo no, but I I I think about that, and it's it's like at some point, because the data is just gonna continue to support these prices. At some point, eventually, the data is gonna have to reject some of these prices, or it's gonna be reflected, like you're saying, upon the agent to price it properly with the seller so that way that stuff doesn't happen.
SPEAKER_02And the issue, Dan, I know you can hit on this even more, but the the it the major issue really is is you have two different types of value you have value of how much that home is and value of how much it's worth to the buyer. So just because that home truly is worth $350, it has multiple comps that say $350 supports that. That does not mean that's what the value of the home is. So that's like real estate agents are losing their minds because it's listed at $350 and it's just and it's priced right, it's okay. Like you're gonna get $350, but you're not getting the bite, you're not you're getting a price reduction, you're still not getting the bite. It's just homes are worth what they are to people, you know, to the customer, you know, and that's it's a tough spot for you guys to be in, Dan.
SPEAKER_01It is, it is. But the there's a lot of truth to that, you know. They always say whatever you know, a home is worth whatever someone's willing to pay for it. Well, that that's true.
SPEAKER_02Yeah,
Blake Elsneryeah, and like some of the yeah, some of these ones are like if somebody's willing to pay a crazy amount, then that becomes a comp, right? And then like it doesn't really necessarily help, I guess, the future of prices. It's just gonna support keep supporting a higher price. So yeah, I guess at some point, you know, I guess, but I think there's less of that, less of people doing silly stuff, yeah. Just kind of just emotional buying. I feel like it's kind of gone out the window a little bit. So that's that's gonna be good. A little more little more data driven, like you said, and I think that's gonna hopefully help increase the market. And I believe, you know, I think rates kept going down. I think they ticked back up this week, right, Drew? Is that
SPEAKER_02a little bit? We're actually getting a little bit of help. I'm looking at a chart right now. We're getting a little bit of help this week. Last week we got punched in the gut, and and really the they're talking about a 50-bip hike in December, which unf I mean, truthfully, the market needs. The market needs a hike in December, the market needs a hike in January, no doubt about it. It's it's frustrating, but they're they have to they have to slow down inflation, or we're gonna just drag out seven percent interest rates for quite a while. It's gonna be really, really bad for a short term. But like we said, I mean, it creates a lot of leverage, you know. Even if interest rates do tick up a quarter, which sounds really horrible, you are showing price reductions, you are showing credits. And so even ten thousand dollars off a home, you know, that is pretty comparable to dropping your interest rate to you know a quarter point, three-eighths of a point. They might be able to level out that way. If rates do want to come down, you can you can take advantage of possibly refinancing. So it's just I again, I I I talk about this a lot, and and I know you guys hear it all the time. It's anybody that wants to buy a home,
Upgrades That Actually Move Value
SPEAKER_02they don't want to bring it up to their friends because they don't want to get judged. They don't want to you're buying a home right now in this economy. Are you are you out of your mind? And it's like you have no idea the the opportunities, Dan. How many, how many appraisals have you seen with closing cost credits recently? I will bet my bottom dollar that it is probably more than you've ever seen in terms of the negotiation power under list with credits, and I wish buyers actually knew that.
SPEAKER_01The other thing I'll add is there's a lot of listings right now where they're offering that um 10,000 buy down by the rate instead of doing a price reduction.
SPEAKER_02100%. Yeah,
Blake Elsnerwe're
SPEAKER_02gonna do that.
Blake ElsnerI think it's brilliant.
SPEAKER_01I do too.
Blake ElsnerIt is smart, it it does. And I think like you're saying about these credits, like letting buyers know and educating them, like, hey, like that is a those credits are massive. They're gonna you know put you even farther ahead of even a 25 uh basis rate increase. Like you said, you're gonna eat that way, you know, way up front with the with a ten thousand dollar credit. So I think like you said, the those aren't those rate moves really aren't gonna do a whole lot if you have an experienced agent, you have an experienced lender in your corner, so that way they know how to navigate all that stuff and actually make you come out actually ahead, right? That's the that's the big part because I feel like there are ways to save thousands, and somebody else down the down the road can just ignore all that, and you're not even gonna realize that you just left thousands on the table, like stuff like that. So I think it's it's crucial to have people in your corner
SPEAKER_02that
Blake Elsnerare experienced.
SPEAKER_01Yes,
SPEAKER_02for sure.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, oh
Blake Elsneryeah. So what what is a here's one thing that I I see uh a lot, Dan, in terms of appraisals is like what's the deal when a computer just accepts it? How does that work?
SPEAKER_01What do you mean?
Blake ElsnerLike you the the data is there, it just accepts it. So that's more on my side. Is that on your side?
SPEAKER_02That's more on my side, yeah. So when we we we run our systems, we run an unwriting system, whether we go Fanny, whether we go Freddie, and conventional will either give us two different and Dan. Do you do PDRs as well?
SPEAKER_01No,
SPEAKER_02no, so I think those are specific. So you can get three different things. You can get a full appraisal, you can do a uh what's called like an ACE plus PDR. I mean, I know it's a bunch of different acronyms, or just a full on ACE, which is an ACE is a true property inspection waiver. And really what that means is my systems have ran because remember what I said at the beginning, these appraisals, yes, important to the buyer, just as much, if not more, important to the the servicer for who is taking on this loan. So when when I run my system, we have a $350,000 purchase price. I run it, it runs its systems. I don't know what systems it looks at, I don't know how it's collecting that data, but it will. I mean, we always hope. Dan, I love helping out businesses. Don't get me wrong, but I'm telling you, when I get a property inspection waiver, I am ecstatic. We're saving money, our time frame is a lot easier. Really, what that means is that home has the value that it believes is comfortable with, it doesn't even need an appraisal. It's okay moving forward because they don't feel like they over you know bought for that home. And I and I still present it to the buyers, they very well still can get an appraisal. And I've had many people that are like, I don't care, I want to know exactly what that home is worth that I'm buying, and I'm perfectly fine with that. But it gives them the opportunity if they don't want to, you know, we were able. to waive you know that appraisal fee of course and and kind of keep the process moving a little bit smoother.
Blake ElsnerYeah okay so that's that's on your your corner because I I never really you know you'll you'll hear about that and I'm like well so you they don't have to yeah you don't have to buy an appraisal which obviously is is interesting because it just shows that there's so much data inside your system that if the purchase price I'm sure is conservative enough it's just gonna say okay yeah we the value's there so
SPEAKER_02and one of the big things is is they like to see a lot of equity so usually 20% down you know because what they're saying is is yes that home very well might be it could be 345 but it probably is 350 a little bit higher. We have so much equity as the say the servicer the investor what we kind of call it there's so much equity there that we're comfortable with that value because really what they're protecting is if something happens that borrower they have to foreclose they aren't able to pay that mortgage they they need to make sure that that asset that they took the risk on is worth it to get off their books and that there's still equity that they're not going to lose money on it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah
Blake Elsnerthat yeah
Pricing Right Days On Market Shifts
Blake Elsnerfollow up Dan
SPEAKER_01no
Blake Elsneroh
SPEAKER_01no sorry
Blake Elsnerno you're good so that so then obviously that that would never even make it today and then and if they obviously wanted a full appraisal then obviously it would it would make it make it today and so that's I think a great point in terms of because you see that a lot nowadays to where the it just gets accepted you're like I mean you're waiting for like an appraiser to to schedule an appointment you're like no they never did I guess it was just I guess it was accepted.
SPEAKER_02Right.
Blake ElsnerSo stuff like that is interesting.
SPEAKER_01With the new form though what I would add is when we were talking about some of the fear mongering on the appraisal side appraisers were very fearful that more appraisal waivers were going to be part of the change the new change and I don't I
SPEAKER_02I haven't seen it
SPEAKER_01I haven't either I haven't either I mean my order volume is not reflective of that.
Blake ElsnerSo it's a yeah it's there's I guess so many they
SPEAKER_02did I will say like within maybe the last year Fannie Freddie loosened guidelines on on down like anything less than 20% down it was almost always going to be a an appraisal no doubt about it. But I've seen some property inspection waivers as low as 10 and I've seen what's called like a a PDR property database report something I think that's the the exact acronym they still go out they still take pictures but they really are just making sure that the home's not you know destroyed it's more of they are still taking pictures but it's not necessarily up for value. They're not necessarily running crazy comps stuff like that. So it's only it's only half the cost which is really nice saves them a little bit but I've seen that as low as five percent down which can get a little scary you know but again it's I I don't know if they're trying to streamline the process you know no part of me wants to get rid of appraisers of course you know I think there's a lot of benefit keeping the integrity in the market but you're right I thought I because I've it I have an aunt that's an appraiser I have friends that are appraisers it's like I was almost super concerned for them as well
SPEAKER_01yeah
Blake Elsneryeah I guess though you I mean realistically you have to be able to see the condition though like inside the house right so
SPEAKER_01right
Blake ElsnerI feel like there's always going to be it's just kind of like the whole open door thing in Zillow like that clearly worked right to buy houses without really looking at them in in certain areas of that you have no idea the one house next to the next one like St. Louis is just so unique and they obviously have they've gotten crushed and I think that would be very similar if we did that with appraisals to where it all became so automated I feel like the the valuations would get all jacked up so I just don't think
SPEAKER_01yeah yeah
Blake Elsnerdon't think it would benefit a lot. It's just yeah I just I don't think that'll come but obviously if the value's there and the the data's there I think in the in the clearly then it'll it'll work. So any any final things we want to cover here before we let all this let all this go and obviously if you missed any of this this will be a podcast episode as well so you'll be able to go back listen to all this again and if you ever need any questions help we're we're all here for you I mean we're glad glad to answer. So any final comments from from you Drew or Dan
SPEAKER_02I I just think kind of to summarize I know we covered a lot but it we were very afraid at the beginning and that fear has been significantly brought down there's there's obviously a lot more work that appraisers are going through but good appraisers
Appraisal Waivers Explained By Lenders
SPEAKER_02like Dan you know they are getting through them even faster they're learning these new systems and it's going to protect the market so there's definitely a lot of positivity there but in terms of crazy time frames I I'm sure and that's also too you know a plug I mean that's why you need to be working with lenders that understand these changes still understanding where guy you know where turn times and processes look and so I have no fear on our side we've done multiple of these new appraisals and have it and have had zero issues with our normal turn times that we've been doing for years. So I it's very exciting I will just say take note and make sure that you guys as listing agents understand what will make these appraisers jobs easier so that your process so that the sales process goes smoother your sellers are happy everybody's happy and we can continue you know rolling through this business.
Blake ElsnerYeah it's great great information Drew and I think Dan will probably piggyback on that to basically say like probably his closing is going to be to tell you to improve that input
SPEAKER_01yes improve the input and then like Drew was saying I'll I'll just feed back that I I've done a number of the new forms it's not nothing to be scared of and the the turnaround time is equal and you know moving forward I I with whenever there's a change I think people worry about it and we'll get through it and every nothing will will lag behind.
Blake ElsnerYeah that's the that's I think the good part is that nothing's like like you said you've done dozens of these now already so like the the issues are they're only going to get like squeezed and smaller so the timing and the reporting I think is only going to get better from here. So like I said from from a scared standpoint I don't think there's really anything to to worry about in terms of this obviously it's a change change is scary right but I think that's why we're coming on here to help you know that hey here's a here's a lender here's an appraiser if you ever have questions these two guys are always open to helping and I think that's crucial to a successful transaction so I appreciate it guys thanks for coming on here and obviously I want to want to give a big uh shout out obviously to Dan to Drew taking out taking time out of their day to come share their knowledge and experience with us and of course to everybody who tuned in again this will be shared as a podcast episode again and I hope that whether it's you know the new appraisal reporting requirements the updated you know lending guidelines or how we navigate the challenges during a transaction there's always something new to learn and I think sometimes as realtors we get so caught up in the day-to-day that we forget just how important it is to continue to educate ourselves because at the end of the day our clients don't hire us to open doors write contracts or just put a sign in the yard they hire us for our knowledge our experience and our ability to guide them through situations they don't deal with every day. And I think that's where our value comes from so I appreciate you guys coming on here and spewing some knowledge and I hope everyone took away something
SPEAKER_01thank you
SPEAKER_02thanks for having us on
Blake Elsnerthanks Dan thanks Drew and thanks everybody for joining us go ahead and get out there
Key Takeaways And Final Advice
Blake Elsnersupport local and enjoy the beautiful weather we have right now because man it's perfect out there. All right until next time one love
SPEAKER_02see you boys
SPEAKER_01video